The board was turning over. The organization needed a way to build what came next.
A 12-year-old nonprofit worked with Warren Whitney to create a board cultivation process, prepare for major board turnover, and add eight new board members.
Nonprofit
SERVICES WE PROVIDED
Board development, board cultivation, nominations process, board matrix, board member expectations, new board member orientation
SUPPORT TYPE
Board development facilitation and governance planning
OUTCOME
The organization added six new board members to replace departing members and two additional members to fill vacancies.
THE STORY
Preparing the board before institutional knowledge rotated off.
After 12 years of operation, a nonprofit was approaching a major governance transition. Its originating and early board members had begun rotating off the board, and the organization realized that, within a few years, it could have a complete turnover in board membership.
The organization did not have a clear plan for identifying, cultivating, nominating, and orienting new board members. Warren Whitney facilitated a board cultivation committee and helped the organization build a process it could continue using as board needs changed.
The work helped the nonprofit replace departing board members, fill open seats, and create a more intentional approach to board cultivation. The organization added six new members to replace departing members and two more people to fill vacancies. The process continues because board cultivation is ongoing work, not a one-time recruitment push.
The Situation
The nonprofit was facing a predictable but important problem: many of the people who had helped shape the organization from the beginning were nearing the end of their board service. Without a plan, the organization risked losing institutional knowledge, committee continuity, and key skills at the same time.
The board needed a clearer view of when members would complete their terms, what committees they served on, and which skills would need to be replaced. It also needed a more consistent nominations process, written expectations for prospective board members, and a practical way to introduce potential members to the organization before asking them to join.
Key needs included:
• Prepare for significant board turnover over the next few years
• Identify which board skills and committee roles would need to be replaced
• Create a board matrix showing term completion dates and committee assignments
• Establish priorities for identifying and cultivating future board members
• Create a nominations process for board review and approval
• Develop written board member expectations for prospective members
• Build a list of potential board members who may be interested in the organization
• Determine how to introduce prospective members to the organization and assess fit
• Develop and conduct an orientation process for new board members
Warren Whitney’s Role
A board development process built around continuity, fit, and clear expectations.
Warren Whitney facilitated the board cultivation committee and guided the group through each step of building a repeatable board cultivation process. The work began with a board matrix that showed when members would complete their terms and which committees they served on.
That matrix helped the committee see future gaps before they became urgent. Warren Whitney then helped the organization create a nominations process, write board member expectations, and build a list of potential candidates for consideration.
The process also included determining the best way to introduce prospective board members to the organization and assessing whether each person would be a good fit. Warren Whitney also assisted with developing and conducting an orientation for new board members so they could join with clearer context and expectations.
Our Value
A stronger plan and a stronger management team.
Before and After
From upcoming board turnover to a more intentional board cultivation process.
Before Warren Whitney
-
Originating and early board members rotating off
-
Possible complete board turnover within a few years
-
No formal plan for bringing on new board members
-
Unclear future gaps in skills and committee participation
-
No written expectations for prospective board members
-
Need for a stronger orientation process
After Warren Whitney
- Board matrix showing terms and committee service
- Clearer priorities for replacing skills and committee roles
- Board-approved nominations process
- Written board member expectations
- Candidate list and cultivation approach
- Orientation process for new board members
- Six replacement board members and two vacancy appointments
Need Similar Support?
Planning for board turnover? Warren Whitney can help your nonprofit build a board cultivation process, clarify future needs, and prepare new members to serve well. Contact us to start a conversation.
Data Directions Inc.